Unsustainable Appetite in FX, Equities & Oil

by Ashraf Laidi
Aug 13, 2009 16:38 | 200 Comments

The Faces of Dissipating Appetite

The 4 charts below display the emerging challenges for risk overall risk appetite as manifested through EURUSD, GBPUSD, S&P500 and US crude oil. The latter is increasingly considered as the lifeblood of overall risk appetite, showing recurring failure to break above the $73 level and the negative momentum divergence, as seen by falling stochastics and a flattening price. A similar negative divergence is seen in the S&P500 (as is the case in most equity indices), facing key resistance at 1,015-- the 38% retracement of the decline from all time high of October 2007 to the low of March 2009.

And as appetite diminishes, currencies such as EUR and GBP tend to lose ground vs. USD and JPY. The 2 top charts (EURUSD and GBPUSD) show increasing difficulty in regaining recent upside and are gradually vulnerable to prolonged losses. Despite regaining $1.43, EURUSD is unlikely to hold above this figure in light of the unsustainable risk picture. $1.4090 remains a near-term target, before a retest of $1.3750 emerges.

Unsustainable Appetite in FX, Equities & Oil - Euro Sterling  Sp Oil (Chart 1)

We've shown last week how struggling oil prices, a bottoming VIX index and a protracted sell-off in the Shanghai Composite illustrated nascent signs of a turnaround in the appetite for risk. The VIX remains well above its 50-week average and multi-month trend line support of 21 while the Shanghai Composite has lost 10% in less than 2 weeks.

Sterling Nears Key Juncture

We reiterate our bearishness against GBP (from last week's missive) as the Fed appears less generous in its quantitative easing plans relative to the Bank of England after saying it will slow the pace of purchasing the remaining $50 billion in US Treasuries. Although GBPUSD held up above the key technical level of $1.64 (50-day moving average), the chart shows the pair at risk of falling below the 50-day MA, a medium term trend line which effectively denoted the breakdown point between rising and falling trend.

Unsustainable Appetite in FX, Equities & Oil - Cable Aug 12 (Chart 2)

Note how GBPUSD first fell below its 50-day MA in Q3 2008 at the height of the BoE's 180-degree turn in monetary policy in and remained below the average ever since UNTIL March 2009 when the FOMC announced treasury purchases.

And with the Fed hinting it will slow the pace of Treasury purchases (good for USD) at same time as BoE to raise its guilt purchases (bad for GBP), the net effect leaves GBP exposed to potentially deeper losses as the BoE remains the more generous provider of QE.

Wake-up Call to FIFO Believers

The unexpected 0.3% q/q increase in Germany's Q2 GDP comprises a technical end to the recession and a wake-up call to the widely misguided forecasts suggesting the US recovery would precede that of Europe. Those FIFO claims (First-in-First-out) stating the US would be first to exit recession simply because it was first to fall into one where largely based on the magnitude of the fiscal and monetary policy stimulus by the US authorities. But one-time quarterly rebounds in the aftermath of 2-3 consecutive quarterly contractions are not unusual. Government stimuli, auto incentive schemes and inventory restocking remain no substitutes to a secular rebound in consumer power, especially when unemployment rates have yet to stabilize.

In the case of the US, despite the positive growth impact from lower trade gap and inventory restocking, the severity of the US housing downturn and the persistent (not yet stabilized) corrosive impact on US consumers (from escalating foreclosures and rising unemployment) will keep growth in contraction territory until Q4.


Comments (Showing latest 10 of 200) View All Comments
Ashraf Laidi
London, UK
Posts: 0
10 years ago
Oct 11, 2009 15:23
FXFiles, yes, you're correct about stocks rising since this article. look at the other charts in the article. GBP and oil are both down. euro is up

Ashraf
speculator
Posted Anonymously
10 years ago
Oct 10, 2009 1:11
well we are october and my call for a weakening pound is on target and beat barclay's forecast so far.
FX-files
United States
Posted Anonymously
10 years ago
Oct 9, 2009 23:17
Well, it's almost two months later, and the markets here in the U.S. have gone up 7% since you wrote this, Ashraf. Maybe you spoke too soon?
speculator
Posted Anonymously
10 years ago
Aug 22, 2009 14:10
there will come a point soon that usd will not necessarily weaken against stock market strength. it will all be about where are the investment opportunities for growth and other economic factors moving currencies. we can clearly see this with cable. the markets will not allow cable to shoot any higher due to bearish fundamentals despite fantastic UK equity market strength.

risk aversion trades are more likely to prevail strongly in highly uncertain times i.e during the bear market.
raulin
london, UK
Posts: 65
10 years ago
Aug 22, 2009 13:21
Speculator you need to change your rigid mind set if you pay close attention strongly rallying US equities have been seen with US strength against JPY and in turn commodities currency rallying against JPY. You say this a news play , well positive news feeds equity rallies .
Ashraf Laidi
London, UK
Posts: 0
10 years ago
Aug 22, 2009 4:39
S&P500 and Dow are looking increasingly bullish. But im not yet throwing the towel. The VIX and oil charts are some of my validations. We shall see. But GBP looks to be a very dependable sell.

Ashraf
Rob
New York, United States
Posts: 305
10 years ago
Aug 22, 2009 4:29
I will do that Ashraf! Thank you for your time and dedication!
Ashraf Laidi
London, UK
Posts: 0
10 years ago
Aug 22, 2009 4:12
Moe, i too have a short oil posiition via an ETF and im not touching it. See my latest article showing 74.30 to be key resistance in oil. And sterling just CANNOT hold on

Rob, at least USDCAD bounce off its lows just like GBPUSD fell off its highs. Wait it out on USDCAD espclly with oil may be peakinbg near its 200-WEEK MOV AVG

Ashraf
speculator
Posted Anonymously
10 years ago
Aug 21, 2009 19:09
i think whats happening recently is that on days where positive US news comes and stocks rise, the dollar strenghtens as the news outweights the stocks. trading is becoming more tough.

also, sterling is getting beaten hard and has probably topped out for some time.

so the euro is where money seems to be flowing in to for now. i strongly believe things will change in sepember as we are still in holiday mode all over.

Rob
New York, United States
Posts: 305
10 years ago
Aug 21, 2009 18:17
Hi Ashraf,

Would you say the only hope for those long USD/CAD is verbal intervention over the weekend. Esp. considering that Asia will probably eat this up on Sunday and send appetites even higher, thus oil, and CAD? Thanks. Not sure if I should wait it out? Unless of course, this whole thing is V-shaped and we're "out of the woods". I think not but, it's def. not fun to be rational in an irrational market. I did do well with GBP, but unfortunately haven't re-entered this morning. Perhaps I'll re-enter "in Asia". Have a good weekend.