Forum > View Topic
by Ashraf Laidi
Posted: Feb 20, 2010 5:00
Comments: 30765
Posted: Feb 20, 2010 5:00
Comments: 30765
Forum Topic:
EUR
Discuss EUR in this thread
I'm a recent finance MBA (univ of toronto) and still figuring out the forex markets. Your book is a great read. I have a question about how one deciphers cross pairs like EURCAD or GBPAUD. It seems these pairs dont "respect" supports and fib-levels (low liquidity?), but the market just uses them to add "extra fire" to moves, say lower in USDCAD or higher in AUDUSD, by squeezing the EURCAD or GBPAUD longs out further and further.
my question is how can one even be comfortable in the technicals of these (non JPY) cross pairs when they dont quite account for much? or do they?
I write this somewhat incognito as I, too, am a pro prognosticator in my own field - which is decidedly not forex. But I've made money for my clients for 32+ years now, so my approach must have some merit.
And I'm not much of a forum-person since over the years, I have had what must amount to thousands of forums posts either applauding my work - or denigrating it. And for a while, you certainly enjoy the plaudits. But you can really do without the negative crap.
Most of which issues from bitter people with short-term outlooks, who forever seem to spew out "what have you done for me lately?"
So, I no longer look at forums that have my name in them. But I thought I'd ask you a question that intrigues me regarding forex - and specifically the short-term fate of the Euro.
And before I do, I should say that I have read your book and applaud your weaving together the various macro- (and micro-) economic elements you do. Much of this was known to me as I've been in my field for decades now, but I did learn quite a bit.
Having said this, what then are the specific factors that lead you to believe that EUR/USD will touch 1.32 by the end of this month, as you've noted numerous times?
I fully understand Fibonacci levels, retracements, basicaly anything a technician can throw at me - because I use similar stuff in my own work for a living.
Here's my problem with relying too much on technical aspects - or even fundamental ones - too much.
What drives markets? Are markets rational? No. All financial markets are very often highly irrational simply because human beings are often highly irrational.
And when it comes to almost any market-movements, the prime motivators of market activity are what they always have been: fear and greed.
Even the great J.P. Morgan, when asked more than a century ago what he thought about the stock market said, "it is a nervous old lady with a bad stomach." Which pretty much does sum it up, J.P.
I bring this up because the vast majority of people who trade in financial markets have amazingly short memories and sometimes non-existent attention spans.
Take the direction of the Euro - short-term. Now, if we had rational markets, and we looked at every relevant macroeconomic piece of data out there - heck, if we just concentrated on the plight of the PIIGS - no sane person could believe the Euro should rise in value vis-a-vis the USD over the next months because these issues with Portugal, Ireland, Italy, Spain & Greece cannot possibly be resolved in short-order.
We have issues like almost 20% unemployment in sunny Spain; Nobel-laureate economists telling us that Italy will implode from debt; and stats coming out of Greece that are from the Twilight Zone: the average Greek worker retires with 96% of their final salary as a pension - compared to 42% for the average German worker. Reading idiocy like that reminds me of the Alice-in-Wonderland dot.com IPO craze where new issues, with no earnings whatsoever, used to increase 5-fold in one day.
Given the often hair-trigger nature of speculators - and I don't know what someone trading forex can be called otherwise - why shouldn't the proclamations of M. Sarkozy the other day just put a halt to the imminent and immediate drop in the Euro?
I mean, the guy came right out and said (and I'm, paraphrasing), "Greece will not fail. We will bail out Greece." What, that's not enough to stop the Euro's slide? That the leader of the world's
5th-largest economy has said, "no problem, Greece. Tout va bien!"?
Long-term, there's going to be a world of hurt in many EU countries as emergency austerity measures kick in.
But 1.32 by the end of this month? My question, Ashraf, is why would this happen? What additional events over the next 3 weeks can you expect that will be a catalyst of another 450 pip drop?
I've used charts for longer than many of your followers have been alive. Looking at the 1-day chart of EUR/USD, for the last month we've had nothing but a protracted sideways base forming. Why do you think that base will break downward?
You put a lot of effort into your site and your info and insights are quite compelling - and for that I thank you a great deal.
Mr. Ashraf's call for main trend is still valid if you put it in a larger frame and we have to allow the market for certain correction if not trend reverse.
It's my fault. I understand I took too much risk, so I have to pay for it. I just hope that this just does not jump too much, I will have to put money to save account. But it is very tricky to keep pouring money because you never know how GS and other's can take market how far they can take up before the market coming back to fundamentals. They have big pocket, and I took too much risk, so my pocket is lighter than ever.
I do not see any reason why EUR can go up, but it has been. I did not see any reason for GBPUSD to go up from 1.60 to 1.64 before it came crashing down. I took smaller profits of 100 pips and got out and Bam it fell 1200 pips.